Top 10 Best Ice Cream Brands in Hertsmere

Hertsmere's Love Affair with Ice Cream

On a warm summer afternoon in Hertsmere, few treats beat a scoop of ice cream. Families picnic at Aldenham Country Park, walkers explore the Green Belt countryside around Shenley and Radlett, and teenagers gather at dessert parlours along Shenley Road in Borehamwood and Darkes Lane in Potters Bar. Ice cream is no longer just a summer indulgence either, with dessert cafes busy year-round and premium tubs a freezer staple in many local homes.

The UK ice cream market has changed dramatically in recent years. Shoppers now expect real ingredients, adventurous flavours, dairy-free alternatives and ethical sourcing. The brands below stand out for quality, availability in Hertsmere and genuine popularity with local customers.

How We Selected These Brands

We considered taste, ingredient quality, flavour range, availability through local supermarkets and parlours, dietary options and brand reputation. The list includes both national favourites found in Hertsmere freezers and dessert parlour brands with a strong local presence.

The Top 10 Ice Cream Brands Enjoyed in Hertsmere

1. Kaspa's Desserts

Kaspa's has become a go-to dessert destination for families and groups of friends. Its menu of sundaes, waffles, crepes, milkshakes and gelato is generous and indulgent, and its late opening hours make it a popular evening hangout.

2. Creams Cafe

Creams specialises in Italian-style gelato, waffles, cookie dough and freshly made desserts. Its relaxed cafe setting and wide menu appeal to all ages, from children's parties to date nights.

3. Ben and Jerry's

Famous for chunky mix-ins and playful flavour names, Ben and Jerry's is a supermarket favourite across the borough. Its long-standing commitment to Fairtrade ingredients and social causes resonates with many customers, and its non-dairy range has expanded significantly.

4. Haagen-Dazs

Haagen-Dazs is synonymous with rich, dense, premium ice cream. Its short ingredient lists and classic flavours such as Belgian chocolate and vanilla make it a reliable indulgence for special occasions.

5. Jude's

Made in Hampshire, Jude's produces award-winning ice cream with a focus on natural ingredients and sustainability. Its salted caramel, vanilla and plant-based ranges are widely stocked in Hertsmere supermarkets.

6. Mackie's of Scotland

Mackie's is a family-owned Scottish farm business known for its famously creamy traditional ice cream. Its renewable energy credentials and simple, honest recipes make it a firm favourite for fans of classic flavours.

7. Kelly's of Cornwall

Kelly's brings the taste of the Cornish seaside to Hertsmere freezers, using Cornish clotted cream to create a smooth, rich texture. Its Cornish vanilla is a nostalgic classic loved by all generations.

8. Magnum

Magnum remains one of the most popular ice cream bars in the UK, thanks to its thick chocolate shell and smooth vanilla core. Limited-edition flavours keep the range exciting throughout the year.

9. Swedish Glace

Swedish Glace is one of the longest-established dairy-free ice creams in the UK. Its smooth, creamy texture has won over vegan and lactose-intolerant customers throughout the borough.

10. Northern Bloc

Northern Bloc creates chef-inspired, sustainably minded ice cream with interesting flavours and plant-based options. It is increasingly found in independent delis, cafes and premium freezers across Hertfordshire.

Ice Cream Trends in Hertsmere

Dairy-free ice cream has moved firmly into the mainstream, with oat, coconut and almond bases now rivalling dairy for creaminess. Lower-sugar and high-protein options are growing among health-conscious shoppers. Dessert parlours are also embracing social-media-friendly presentation, with elaborate sundaes, freakshakes and colourful toppings drawing younger crowds. Kosher-certified options are important for many families in Borehamwood, Elstree and Radlett.

Tips for Enjoying Ice Cream Responsibly

Check labels carefully for allergens such as nuts, gluten and soy, particularly in mix-in flavours. Store tubs at a consistent temperature to avoid ice crystals, and let premium ice cream soften for a few minutes before serving for the best flavour and texture.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between ice cream and gelato?

Gelato typically contains more milk and less cream than ice cream, is churned more slowly so less air is incorporated, and is served at a slightly warmer temperature. The result is a denser texture and more intense flavour. Traditional ice cream is creamier and richer because of its higher fat content.

Are there good dairy-free ice creams available in Hertsmere?

Yes. Supermarkets across Borehamwood, Potters Bar and Bushey stock a strong selection of plant-based ice creams made from oat, coconut, almond and soy. Dessert parlours increasingly offer vegan gelato and sorbets, so it is worth asking what is available on the day.

Where can families enjoy ice cream outdoors?

Aldenham Country Park near Elstree is a favourite for family days out, and the open spaces around Radlett, Shenley and Potters Bar are ideal for summer picnics. Pairing a walk with a trip to a local parlour makes for an easy, affordable weekend treat.

How can I tell if an ice cream is high quality?

Look for short ingredient lists with real milk, cream, sugar and natural flavourings. Lower air content, often called overrun, gives a denser texture, so a heavier tub for its size is usually a good sign. Brands that name their dairy farms or ingredient sources tend to take quality seriously.

Conclusion

From indulgent dessert parlours to premium supermarket tubs, Hertsmere offers an ice cream option for every craving and dietary need. Next time the sun comes out, or simply when you fancy a treat, these ten brands are a delicious place to start.